This is a list of all our past players who have been chosen to play in either the Indiana/Kentucky All-Star match (now defunct), the ICGSA North-South Cup, or the Indiana Boys All-Star Classic.
ICGSA North/South All-Stars
| Player | Year |
|---|---|
| Alison Peckinpaugh | 2000 |
| Sarah Peckinpaugh | 2002 |
| Adrienne Campbell | 2002 |
| Beth Miller | 2002 |
| Katherine Yadon | 2002 |
| Tricia Gorenc | 2004 |
| Laura Yadon | 2004 |
| Kelsey Atkins | 2004 |
| Katie Bryan | 2006 |
| Kristin Crider | 2007 |
| Hayley Hall | 2007 |
| Kristin McKinney | 2008 |
| Devyn Wafer | 2011 |
| Hailey Humphrey | 2011 |
| Ashley Loffer | 2013 |
| Natalie Alexander | 2013 |
| Marissa Morris | 2013 |
| Madison Ashman | 2014 |
| Teaghan Dishman | 2015 |
| Kaylin Gibson | 2015 |
| Emily Decker | 2016 |
| Mayzie Hinkle | 2019 |
| Janet Wegener | 2023 |
| Gabby Knight | 2024 |
| Brylee Beckley | 2025 |
| Kelsey Vest | 2025 |
Indiana Boy’s Senior All-Star Classic
| Player | Year |
|---|---|
| Ben Bryan | 2010 |
| Ethan Grove | 2011 |
| Evan Rodenberger | 2012 |
| Alec St. John | 2013 |
| Jay Robillard | 2014 |
| Nick Wilson | 2014 |
| Joe Wegener | 2015 |
| Alec Robillard | 2016 |
| Jason Wegener | 2017 |
| Tannon Dishman | 2018 |
| Joel Ashman | 2018 |
| Brandon Jackson | 2020 |
| Tanner Southerland | 2020 |
| Walker Boyle | 2021 |
| Adam Altobella | 2021 |
| Dalton Royal | 2023 |
| Kody Vest | 2024 |
| Aaron Elliott | 2025 |
Indiana/Kentucky All-Stars
| Player | Year |
|---|---|
| Josh Cooper | 1999 |
| Chad Hawk | 1999 |
| Michael Bookmyer | 2000 |
| Alison Peckinpaugh | 2000 |
| Ryan Orr | 2001 |
| Kelly Robbins (Alt) | 2002 |
| Billy Ruxton | 2002 |
| Daniel Jackson | 2002 |
| Sarah Peckinpaugh | 2002 |
| Katherine Yadon | 2002 |